The other day I ran into a friend of mine in the neighborhood. As we were talking, her high school aged son (who I've known since he was seven) came up to her to let her know his evening plans. We live in an "urban village" with a healthy night life walking distance from our homes.
The negotiation was perfect. He was going to hang out -- Mom wants a call once they figure out what they are doing/where they are going. He wants to stay out until 11:30, Mom comes back with 11. Here's how the dialogue looked:
Him: Hey, I'm going out, now (with arm around Mom's shoulder)
Mom: Who's going?
Him: (a few names, girls and boys)
Mom: What are you doing
Him: Don't know, wandering around.
Mom: I want you to call me when you decide and get there.
Him: (polite grumbling) OK. What's my curfew?
Mom: What are you thinking about?
Him: 11:30
Mom: 11:00
Him: Last time it was 12!
Mom: When?
Him: When we were at Joe's house.
Mom: That's at somebody's house -- and I don't remember midnight.
Him: (grumbled resistance)
Mom: I'll talk to Dad, but I think 11:30 is too late. You guys can come back to the house but I want you back by 11.
Him: (something that resembles understanding, if not agreement, a kiss and he meanders, not unhappily, down the sidewalk)
Mom: Text or call or something! (she turns to me) Nothing good happens after 11.
Watching this was a nice glimpse into a good mother/son relationship. Mom's right, the local coffee shops all close before 11. People out on the streets after 11 have often been drinking, and the only places to hang out are places with bars (not that her son would have been served.)
But her son is a typical, well-liked, good-looking 15-year-old. Of course he wants to push back against Mom's decision. It's not about whether Mom's being reasonable. It's the way that he finds out whether she can be counted on. When he pushes back, is Mom going to get out of the way, or is she there to catch him when he is out to experiment with independence?
Of course he wants to stay out later, and, no, he doesn't realize why he's pushing back. He just needs to do it. And Mom shows that she's reliable, and the adult in the relationship, when she sets clear limits.
Does this mean that curfews should be non-negotiable? Absolutely not. Curfews are often negotiable, but that negotiation, the reasons, the process, and the outcome, are all critical parts of the ways we support kids as they navigate adolescence. More on negotiating curfews in a future post.